About this property
Welcome to the formally registered Dudley House at 558 Gay Street, a stunning 1890 late-Victorian estate nestled in the original town surveyed by a 17-year-old George Washington. Situated on land whose title traces back to a 1798 town grant, this architectural gem has just undergone a complete, uncompromising, top-to-bottom reconstruction. While the current owner meticulously preserved the home's 19th-century soul, the renovation brought the house up to modern standards of comfort and efficiency. This is a true down-to-the-studs rebirth, and the home now features entirely new electrical wiring, ductwork, plumbing, a new electric water heater, a state-of-the-art two-zone heat pump system, and an all-new metal standing seam roof. The technical integrity of the Dudley House is unparalleled in the historic market. The structure has been bolstered with new attic insulation and high-performance, aluminum-clad double-hung Marvin windows that offer modern thermal efficiency without sacrificing the home's iconic historic profile. The owner has even pre-installed the infrastructure for a backup generator. Inside, the craftsmanship is felt at every turn, from the beautifully restored original heart pine floors to the spectacular walnut centr
Listing courtesy of: BrightMLS Office — Default Agent Bright
MLS #241591637 · CAAR · Updated May 14, 2026
This information is believed to be accurate, but without warranty.